Trading in Futures & Options (F&O) has become a common income avenue for retail investors and professionals alike. But when it comes to income tax return (ITR) filing, especially in the case of F&O losses, many taxpayers are unsure whether they must undergo a tax audit, how to compute turnover, or how to carry forward such losses properly without attracting notices. Further, the Annual Information Statement (AIS) increasingly captures broker-reported trades, making accurate and consistent disclosure essential.
This blog serves as a complete guide for F&O traders, tax professionals, and business taxpayers, covering:
-
Income classification of F&O losses
-
Tax audit triggers with turnover working as per ICAI
-
Proper ITR filing strategy for loss carry-forward
-
AIS reconciliation & compliance precautions
-
Smart tax planning angles
F&O Loss Is a Non-Speculative Business Loss, Not Speculative
Under Section 43(5) of the Income Tax Act, transactions in F&O (derivatives) carried out on recognized stock exchanges are specifically excluded from being treated as speculative. This means:
-
F&O profit or loss is treated as "business income"—even for individuals or salaried taxpayers.
-
Hence, F&O loss is a non-speculative business loss, eligible for set-off against other business incomes, and for carry-forward under Section 72 for up to 8 assessment years, subject to timely filing.
Tax Audit Applicability in Case of F&O Losses: Law and Logic
A tax audit under Section 44AB is not automatically applicable just because a loss is reported. It depends on turnover, profit percentage, and whether presumptive taxation is opted under Section 44AD.
A. Turnover Computation — ICAI Guidance
As per the ICAI's Guidance Note on Tax Audit, F&O turnover is the absolute value of profits/losses from all trades during the year:
| Component | How It’s Calculated |
|---|---|
| Turnover | Aggregate of positive and negative differences of each trade |
| Premium on Options | Add premiums received on sale of options |
| Reversal Trades (if any) | Add separately if squared off on same day |
Tax Audit Triggers (with or without loss)
| Scenario | Tax Audit Required? |
|---|---|
| Turnover exceeds ₹10 crore, even with digital transactions | Yes (Mandatory) |
| Turnover between ₹2 crore and ₹10 crore, digital transactions ≥95% | No, if digital mode met |
| Turnover below ₹2 crore, and profits <6% (or <8% non-digital) | Yes, unless under 44AD |
| Loss declared, presumptive scheme under 44AD opted & criteria met | No |
| Loss shown, proper books maintained, turnover <₹10 crore | No, if above not breached |
-
Profit is below the deemed % threshold and presumptive scheme is not used, or
-
Turnover exceeds ₹10 crore, or
-
You opt out of 44AD and turnover crosses ₹1 crore.
Proper Books of Account — A Key Relief Angle
Most F&O trades happen via SEBI-registered brokers. As a result:
-
Ledgers, trade summaries, P&L reports, and contract notes from brokers provide a complete record of all trades.
-
These form sufficient basis for maintaining books of account.
So, if proper books are maintained and available, even in case of loss, tax audit is not mandatory, provided turnover and profit thresholds are not breached.
This interpretation aligns with CBDT Circulars and judicial precedents. Books need not be in a traditional cash book–ledger format; professionally maintained digital records suffice.
ITR Filing Strategy for F&O Loss: Avoiding Penalties, Optimising Claims
| Purpose | Condition |
|---|---|
| Carry forward business loss | File ITR within original due date |
| Set off against other income | Allowed only against business income, not salary |
| ITR Form to use | ITR-3 (for business income) |
| Presumptive option (44AD) | Not applicable to F&O, as F&O is not eligible for presumptive income for non-retail trade (ICAI/Dept view) |
AIS/26AS Matching and Reporting Caution
With AIS now reflecting Scrip-wise F&O turnover, options premium, etc. (reported by brokers):
-
Ensure turnover as per AIS ≈ turnover in ITR working
-
Report gross premium on sale of options, not just net loss
-
Match broker’s summary with AIS figures — minor mismatches may trigger compliance notices (e.g., e-verification)
Additional Tax Planning & Compliance Tips
-
Plan tax-saving business expenses (advisory, software, internet) to adjust against F&O profits in profitable years.
-
Maintain a ledger of carry-forward losses, year-wise.
-
Use Form 3CD only if tax audit is applicable.
-
Consider clubbing multiple trading accounts to avoid scattered turnover misclassification.
Final Summary: Don’t Panic Over F&O Loss
| Key Insight | Impact |
|---|---|
| F&O loss is non-speculative business loss | Can be set off and carried forward |
| Tax audit not mandatory only due to loss | Depends on turnover & % of profit/loss |
| Proper books usually available via broker statements | Avoids audit if maintained and turnover <₹10 cr |
| ITR-3 is mandatory for F&O traders | Even if only loss is reported |
| AIS matching is essential | Prevents future scrutiny or mismatch |
Concluding Thought
Reporting F&O losses doesn't mean an audit burden or scrutiny trap—if turnover is computed correctly, books are maintained, ITR is timely filed, and AIS is matched. Follow the right law-backed strategy, and you can preserve your right to carry forward losses without unnecessary compliance stress.
