Secondment may feel like just an internal transfer—but for Indian tax laws, it can mean salary, FTS, or even permanent establishment.
1. What Is Employee Secondment?
Secondment means temporarily sending an employee from a foreign company to work in an Indian company. It happens commonly in:
-
Multinational group companies
-
Technical or consulting assignments
-
Knowledge transfer or senior management support
2. Who Is the Real Employer?
Tax treatment depends on who is the real employer:
Factor | Foreign Company | Indian Company |
---|---|---|
Who pays salary? | ✅ Sometimes | ✅ Sometimes |
Who controls daily work? | ❌ | ✅ |
Who benefits from the work? | ❌ | ✅ |
Who bears risk/liability? | ❌ | ✅ |
3. When Does TDS Apply and Under Which Section?
Situation | TDS Section | Nature |
---|---|---|
Employee works under Indian control | Sec. 192 | Salary |
Indian company reimburses salary without markup | Sec. 192 | Salary |
Foreign company controls employee, sends for services | Sec. 195 | FTS (Fees for Technical Services) |
Reimbursement includes markup or management fee | Sec. 195 + GST | Treated as service, not salary |
4. GST and PE Risk – Easy View
-
GST: Not applicable on pure salary reimbursements. Applicable if reimbursement includes any markup or profit component.
-
Permanent Establishment (PE): If seconded employee acts on behalf of foreign company, signs deals, or manages contracts, the foreign company may be taxed in India.
5. Real Case Summaries (Simplified)
Case | Ruling |
---|---|
Centrica Offshore | Foreign company remained employer → FTS applies |
Morgan Stanley | Seconded employees created PE, but TP pricing protected them |
Yamazen India (2024) | Seconded employee worked under Indian company → Treated as salary |
6. Secondment Models with TDS Planning
Model | Key Features | TDS | Best When |
---|---|---|---|
Pure Salary Reimbursement | Indian company controls work, pays cost without profit | Sec. 192 | Long-term secondment |
Technical Deployment | Foreign company sends employee, includes fee or profit | Sec. 195 | Short-term consulting/tech projects |
Dual Contract | Employee signs with both entities | Sec. 192 (India side) | HR/immigration structuring needs |
7. Simple Compliance Checklist
Do This | ✅ Why It Matters |
---|---|
Sign a secondment agreement | Clarifies employer, control, reimbursement |
Deduct TDS under correct section | Avoid penalties (Sec. 192 vs 195) |
Avoid markup in cost-sharing | To prevent FTS & GST |
Keep supporting documents | For audits or queries |
Disclose in Form 3CEB (if group company) | Transfer Pricing requirement |
8. Common Mistakes to Avoid
🚫 Reimbursing salary with profit or fee
🚫 Letting seconded employee sign contracts on behalf of foreign company
🚫 Using vague agreements with no control clarification
🚫 Not deducting TDS at all due to foreign payroll assumption
9. Final Takeaway: Make Secondment Clean and Compliant
-
Control = Employer for tax purposes.
-
If Indian company benefits from seconded employee’s work, treat it as salary and deduct TDS under Section 192.
-
Avoid fee-like structures or loose documentation—they invite GST, FTS classification, and PE risk.
“Structure the secondment right from day one. Otherwise, compliance will chase you later.”