In AY 2025-26, tax audit applicability under Section 44AB of the Income-tax Act, 1961 is primarily determined by turnover, cash transaction limits, and presumptive scheme eligibility.
With the threshold now extending up to ₹10 crores for digitally compliant businesses, numerous nuances and tricky scenarios arise for proprietors, professionals, NRIs, and F&O traders. This guide addresses the toughest queries, provides legal reasoning, and presents a practical matrix for decision-making.
Query 1: Is Tax Audit Required if Turnover > ₹5 Crores but Cash Receipts & Payments ≤5%?
Answer: No
Reasoning:
-
The Finance Act raised the threshold to ₹10 crores for businesses maintaining both cash receipts and payments ≤5% of total transactions.
-
This incentivizes digital compliance and focuses audits where cash intensity is high, which is historically more prone to under-reporting.
Query 2: Can Return Be Filed Without a Tax Audit Report?
Answer: Yes, if conditions are met
Explanation:
-
Turnover < ₹10 crores and 5% cash test satisfied → tax audit report not mandatory.
-
Maintain supporting schedules for the 5% calculation and reconciliation; these may be requested during assessment.
Query 3: Is Section 44AD Presumptive Taxation Allowed if Turnover > ₹5 Crores?
Answer: No
Explanation:
-
44AD applies only to turnover ≤ ₹2 crores (or ≤3 crores for ≥95% digital receipts).
-
Exceeding the threshold disqualifies the assessee from the presumptive scheme → regular books and ITR-3 must be used.
Query 4: Does Past Tax Audit Trigger Future Audit Requirement?
Answer: No
Explanation:
-
Audit applicability is year-specific, based on current turnover and cash ratios.
-
Prior audits do not create an obligation unless voluntary exit from 44AD triggers the 5-year lock-in rule.
Query 5: If Earlier Years Were under Section 44AD, Can This Year Be Filed Without Audit?
Answer: Yes, provided criteria are met
Explanation:
-
When turnover exceeds presumptive thresholds, 44AD cannot be used → regular provisions apply.
-
Audit is triggered only if turnover or cash thresholds demand it.
-
Lock-in applies only on voluntary exit, not statutory ineligibility due to turnover rise.
Master Query: Low Profit (<6%/8%) or Loss, Turnover <10 Crores, Clause-Wise Applicability, F&O Trading
Answer:
-
Turnover ≤10 crores AND cash ≤5% → No audit, even for profits below 6%/8% or losses.
-
6%/8% benchmarks apply only under presumptive schemes (44AD/44ADA). Outside these schemes, audit is turnover-driven.
-
Turnover >10 crores → audit always mandatory.
F&O Rules:
-
Cannot opt for 44AD.
-
F&O turnover >10 crores triggers audit for all business activities.
-
Unified audit: If any business triggers audit, all activities must be audited.
Clause-Wise Section 44AB Mapping
| Clause | Trigger | Profit % Matters? | Rationale |
|---|---|---|---|
| 44AB(a) | Business turnover > ₹1 crore (limit ₹10 cr if cash ≤5%) | No | Pure turnover test |
| 44AB(b) | Professional receipts > ₹50/75 lakhs | No | Based on receipts, not profit margin |
| 44AB(c) | 44AD profit <6%/8% & income > exemption | Yes | Prevent misuse of 44AD |
| 44AB(d/e) | 44ADA, 44AE, 44BB, 44BBB | Yes | Profit below deemed rate triggers audit |
Practical Examples Matrix
| Turnover | Cash ≤5% | Profit % | Audit? | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ₹8.5 cr | Yes | 4% | ❌ No | Turnover <10 cr, outside 44AD |
| ₹1.5 cr | N/A | 5% | ✅ Yes* | Under 44AD, profit <6%/8% |
| ₹12 cr | Any | Any | ✅ Yes | Turnover >10 cr; audit triggered |
| ₹9.8 cr | No | 5% | ✅ Yes | 5% test failed; ₹1 cr threshold applies |
| F&O ₹12 cr + Business ₹2 cr | Yes | 7% | ✅ Yes | F&O triggers audit for all businesses |
Query 7: Professionals under Section 44ADA
Answer: Yes
-
Audit required if professional receipts >50 lakhs (or 75 lakhs for ≥95% digital receipts).
-
Profits below deemed rates also trigger audit.
Query 8: Business Turnover ₹9.8 Cr, Cash Transactions 6%
Answer: Audit required
-
The elevated ₹10 crore limit applies only if both cash receipts & payments ≤5%.
-
Breach reduces threshold to ₹1 crore.
Query 9: NRIs / RNORs
Answer: Audit applies if thresholds met
-
Cash/digital ratio test is identical.
-
Maintain Indian books and inward remittance reconciliation.
Query 10: Turnover < ₹1 Crore but Books Not Maintained
Answer: Audit not required
-
Books maintenance (44AA) still applies if income exceeds exemption limit.
-
Non-compliance can lead to assessment issues.
Query 11: Voluntary Audit
Answer: Yes
-
Performed for business, banking, or tender requirements.
-
Reports not uploaded unless 44AB mandates.
Query 12: Penalties for Non-Compliance
-
Section 271B: 0.5% of turnover, maximum ₹1.5 lakh
-
Section 273B: Relief if reasonable cause is demonstrated
Golden Thumb Rules for AY 2025-26
-
Turnover ≤10 crores + cash ≤5% → No audit
-
Turnover >10 crores → Audit mandatory
-
Professionals: Receipts >50/75 lakhs → Audit required
-
Presumptive schemes: Audit if profits below deemed %
-
F&O: Cannot use 44AD; turnover >10 cr → Audit mandatory
-
Failure to comply → penalties under 271B unless reasonable cause shown
Compliance Checklist
-
Compute and document 5% cash limits precisely.
-
Reconcile bank/POS/gateway with books.
-
Maintain full books, especially if outside 44AD.
-
Prepare Form 3CD working papers in anticipation.
-
For F&O, ensure computation aligns with ICAI/Income Tax guidelines.
Key Points to Remember
-
Audit outside presumptive schemes is always turnover-driven.
-
Low profits or losses do not trigger audit if digital compliance and turnover thresholds are satisfied.
-
Accurate documentation is the best defense against inquiries.
-
Use this FAQ + matrix to guide clients, practitioners, or students through AY 2025-26.
