Clause 31 of Form 3CD: Comprehensive Advisory with Clause-Wise Guidance

Introduction

Clause 31 of Form 3CD is one of the most critical disclosures in a tax audit report under the Income Tax Act, designed to ensure transparency in cash transactions and adherence to prohibitions under Sections 269SS, 269T, and 269ST.

The objective of Clause 31 is to:

• Provide full visibility of cash transactions involving loans, deposits, immovable property advances, and high-value receipts/payments.

• Prevent contraventions that may attract penalties under Sections 271D, 271E, 271DA, and 271J.

• Enable auditors and management to proactively monitor threshold breaches, reconcile records, and mitigate penalty exposure.

The framework below provides a clause-wise, analytical, and actionable advisory for robust compliance.

Clause-Wise Advisory & Analytical Guidance

Clause 31(a) – Acceptance of Loans or Deposits

Objective: Report loans or deposits exceeding ₹20,000 from a single person.

Columns Required:

• Name & Address

• PAN/Aadhaar

• Amount Accepted

• Squared Up (Y/N)

• Maximum Outstanding Balance

• Mode & Code (Cash, Cheque, Transfer, Journal)

Guidance:

• Include journal entries, interest capitalization, and transfer entries.

• Exclude trade payables, share application money, and security deposits.

• Aggregate all transactions party-wise; compute peak exposure to track maximum liability.

• Mode code classification: Highlight non-account payee usage (Codes C/D) for targeted verification.

Clause 31(b) – Acceptance of Specified Sums for Immovable Property

Objective: Report advances exceeding ₹20,000 received for transfer of immovable property.

Columns Required:

• Name & Address

• PAN/Aadhaar

• Amount Received

• Maximum Outstanding Balance

• Mode & Code

Guidance:

• Include earnest money, booking amounts, and part payments.

• Aggregate per person, regardless of whether property transfer has occurred.

• Reconcile reported sums with sale agreements, memorandum of understanding (MRL), and books of accounts.

Clause 31(ba) & 31(bb) – High-Value Receipts (269ST)

Objective: Report receipts ≥ ₹2 lakh in cash (31ba) or non-account payee cheque (31bb) in a day/transaction/event.

Columns Required:

• Name & Address

• PAN/Aadhaar

• Nature of Transaction

• Amount

• Date

• Mode & Code

Guidance:

• Exclude receipts from banks, government, or cooperative entities.

• Verify cheque images where applicable.

• Apply daily, transaction-wise, and event-wise aggregation tests to capture 269ST breaches.

Clause 31(bc) & 31(bd) – High-Value Payments (269ST)

Objective: Report payments ≥ ₹2 lakh in cash (31bc) or non-account payee cheque (31bd).

Columns Required: Same as receipts.

Guidance:

• Verify payments using bank statements and vouchers.

• Reconcile with purchase invoices, expense ledgers, or party accounts.

• Track repeat cash payments to assess reliance on prohibited modes.

Clause 31(c) – Repayment of Loans or Deposits

Objective: Report all repayments exceeding ₹20,000 per person.

Columns Required:

• Name & Address

• PAN/Aadhaar

• Amount Repaid

• Maximum Outstanding Balance

• Mode & Code

Guidance:

• Include repayments by cash, cheque, ECS, or journal adjustments.

• Report separately from fresh acceptances under 31(a); no netting allowed.

• Maintain rolling daily balances to capture maximum outstanding liability.

Analytical & Procedural Recommendations

1. Data Collation: Extract cash book, bank book, journal entries, and subsidiary ledgers; tag by party, date, amount, and mode code.

2. Threshold Filtering: Automate identification of transactions exceeding ₹20,000 (loans/deposits) or ₹2 lakh (269ST).

3. Maximum Outstanding Analysis: Maintain daily schedules and flag spikes for review.

4. Risk Scoring & Trend Analysis: Score counterparties by cash usage, non-account payee frequency, and repeated 269ST breaches; implement real-time alerts.

5. Penalty Exposure Estimation: Calculate potential penalties under Sections 271D, 271E, 271DA, and 271J; discuss corrective measures with management.

Professional Cautions & Disclaimers

• Per Party Aggregation: Limit applies per person, not per transaction.

• Peak Balance: Report the highest balance during the year, not the closing balance.

• Account-Payee Verification: Photocopies may be imperfect; include disclaimers where evidence is limited.

Sample Disclaimers:

• “Verification of account-payee status not possible due to lack of evidence.”

• “Voluminous data prevented detailed checking of all transactions.”

• Maintain audit trail, working papers, and professional judgments to comply with ICAI’s TAQRB review requirements.

Implementation Checklist

• Extract, tag, and reconcile ledgers

• Automate aggregation for thresholds

• Compute peak balances and assign mode codes

• Prepare party-wise schedules with supporting evidence

• Estimate penalty exposure and discuss with management

• Insert ICAI standard disclaimers

• Document professional judgments and audit trail

•