By CA Surekha S Ahuja
Statutory Foundation — Why Surcharge Applies on “Total Income” and Not “Taxable Income”
Meaning of Total Income: Section 2(45)
Total income means the total amount of income referred to in section 5, computed under all heads of income, before applying:
-
Chapter III exemptions
-
Chapter VI-A deductions
-
Rebates such as section 87A
This definition has never been amended and continues to be the legal basis for surcharge determination up to AY 2025–26.
Judicial Interpretation
Courts have consistently held that:
-
Exemptions reduce tax liability, not income slabs or surcharge thresholds.
-
Surcharge is calculated on total income before exemptions.
This principle has been reinforced in decisions such as:
-
Kotak Mahindra Primus Ltd. (Bombay High Court)
-
K. Raasi (Madras High Court)
Thus, total income for surcharge = income computed under sections 14–59 before granting any exemptions under Chapter III.
Finance Act Surcharge Triggers for AY 2025–26
Individuals / HUFs / AOPs
| Total Income | Surcharge | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Up to ₹50 lakh | Nil | — |
| ₹50 lakh – ₹1 crore | 10 percent | Triggered even if threshold is crossed due to exempt long-term capital gain |
| ₹1 crore – ₹2 crore | 15 percent | LTCG surcharge capped at 15 percent |
| ₹2 crore – ₹5 crore | 25 percent | LTCG surcharge continues to be capped |
| Above ₹5 crore | 25 percent (new regime) or 37 percent (old regime) | LTCG surcharge always capped at 15 percent |
Companies and LLPs
-
Domestic company:
-
7 percent if total income exceeds ₹1 crore
-
12 percent if total income exceeds ₹10 crore
-
-
LLPs and Firms:
-
12 percent above ₹1 crore
-
There is no surcharge cap on capital gains for corporates or LLPs.
Inclusion–Exclusion Rules for Surcharge Threshold
Included in Total Income (and therefore push the assessee into surcharge)
-
Exempt long-term capital gain
-
Partner’s exempt share under section 10(2A)
-
Agricultural income (for rate purposes)
-
Special rate gains under sections 111A, 112, 112A
-
Foreign income before applying DTAA relief
Excluded from Total Income (do not affect surcharge applicability)
-
Deductions under Chapter VI-A
-
Rebates under sections 87A and 89
-
Carried forward losses
-
Rebate-linked incomes under section 87A
Practical Insight
Even one rupee above ₹50 lakh — even if it is purely exempt income — triggers surcharge.
Software Confusion Explained — Why Older Utilities Ignored Exempt LTCG
Before AY 2019–20, ITR utilities displayed “Taxable Total Income”, not total income under section 2(45).
Because exempt LTCG had no tax effect, the display did not add it to the “total income” field.
Legally, however:
-
Exempt income was always part of total income
-
Exempt income always influenced surcharge
CBDT corrected the display and schema from AY 2019–20 onwards to match the law.
Thus, the change was a software/UI correction, not a change in tax policy.
Illustration — Individual with Exempt LTCG (Most Important Example)
Facts
-
Salary income: ₹45 lakh
-
Exempt LTCG: ₹7 lakh
-
Taxable income: ₹45 lakh
-
Total income for surcharge: ₹52 lakh
Computation
-
Tax under new regime: ₹4,28,400
-
Surcharge @10 percent: ₹42,840
-
Pre-relief tax: ₹4,71,240
Since income above ₹50 lakh is only ₹2 lakh, marginal relief applies.
-
Maximum tax allowable after relief: ₹2 lakh
-
Relief amount: ₹4,71,240 − ₹2 lakh = ₹2,71,240
-
Tax after relief: ₹2 lakh
-
Cess @4 percent: ₹8,000
Final tax payable: ₹2,08,000
This example clearly demonstrates:
-
Exempt LTCG increases total income
-
Surcharge becomes applicable
-
Marginal relief prevents excessive burden
Illustration — Domestic Company with Capital Gains
-
Business income: ₹11 crore
-
LTCG: ₹1 crore
-
Total income: ₹12 crore
Tax Calculation
-
Income tax @25 percent: ₹3 crore
-
Surcharge @12 percent: ₹36 lakh
-
Cess @4 percent: ₹12.24 lakh
Total tax payable: ₹3,48,24,000
Closing Perspective — What Professionals Must Take Away
Surcharge is no longer a mechanical add-on.
It is a rate-shifting, threshold-sensitive, and computation-altering lever that influences tax outcomes for individuals, promoters, funds, corporates, LLPs, and cross-border taxpayers alike.
Three principles ultimately define correct surcharge planning:
1. Total income — not taxable income — drives surcharge exposure.
Exempt LTCG, partner’s exempt share, agricultural income for rate purposes, and special-rate incomes all push the taxpayer across surcharge bands, even if not taxable.
2. Marginal relief must always be checked — and never assumed.
From salaried individuals with exempt gains to HNIs with mixed incomes, incorrect relief computation remains one of the highest scrutiny triggers in CASS.
3. Structuring decisions matter far more today.
Capital gain timing, bonus/redemption sequencing, business restructuring, partner remuneration design, and dividend distribution policy all create real surcharge arbitrage when executed consciously.
